top of page

Your Breath Does Not Have to Follow Mine: Making Room for Choice in Guided Listening

Writer: Julie Jewels Smoot
Julie Jewels Smoot
2 days ago
4 min read

By Sound Alchemist Julie Jewels Smoot


A peaceful lakeside retreat featuring a cozy chair with a knit blanket and a Tibetan singing bowl, set against a backdrop of misty mountains and vibrant autumn foliage.
A peaceful lakeside retreat featuring a cozy chair with a knit blanket and a Tibetan singing bowl, set against a backdrop of misty mountains and vibrant autumn foliage.

“Take a deep breath.”


It is a familiar opening. Sometimes it feels welcome. Sometimes, before we have even found a comfortable place to sit, it gives us another instruction to carry out.


Perhaps the breath already feels comfortable. Perhaps drawing attention to it brings uneasiness. Perhaps we came to listen because we needed a few minutes without anyone telling us what to do.


In my guided listening work, I want to leave room for those possibilities.


Your breath does not have to follow mine.


You can hear my voice without matching its rhythm. You can listen to a singing bowl without breathing in time with its resonance. You can let a gong fade while your breathing continues in its own way.


There is room for you here.


An invitation needs room for an answer


When I offer a suggestion, I want the listener to have a meaningful choice about accepting it.


“You might notice your breathing, if that feels comfortable.”


That sentence leaves several possibilities open. Someone may become curious about their breath. Someone else may keep their attention on the sound. Another person may decide to look around the room.


The words that follow matter, too. If I immediately begin counting and expect everyone to keep up, the choice becomes harder to exercise.


A more spacious invitation might be:


“You can follow this rhythm, stay with your natural breathing, or let the counting pass in the background.”


Then I need to allow enough quiet for the listener to find their own response.


A shared room can hold different rhythms


In a group, it is easy to assume that everyone should move together.


There can be beauty in shared rhythm. There can also be comfort in knowing that participation does not depend on matching it.


One person may enjoy a breathing cue. Another may prefer to feel the support of the chair. Someone may shift their feet, adjust a blanket, or keep their eyes open.


I want my sessions to accommodate those ordinary differences.


The recording continues, but the listener does not owe it a particular pattern of breathing. My voice offers company. It does not need to become a pace they must maintain.

What research invites us to consider


A 2026 randomized crossover study asked 42 university students to try three brief breathing protocols, each paced relative to their usual breathing rate. Slower conditions produced greater relaxation on average and changes in physiological measures. Individual responses varied, however, and minor adverse events were reported. Participants with greater anxious-depressive symptoms also reported more stress after the practice.


The researchers emphasized personalization and tolerability. This was a small, short-term study, largely involving people with previous relaxation experience; it was not evidence that everyone should breathe at the same rate or that slow breathing treats trauma. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov


For me, the practical question is simple: Can the listener change the practice when it does not fit?


A guided experience should have room for that answer to be yes.


Attention can go somewhere else


A listening session does not have to begin inside the body.


I can invite someone to notice a sound in the room, the colors around them, or the place where their feet meet the floor. They may choose to follow a bowl’s fading tone. They may simply sit and let the recording play.


These are options I offer rather than steps everyone must complete.


Even the suggestion to “notice” can become tiring when it arrives repeatedly. Sometimes I want to leave a stretch of sound without a question attached to it.


No instruction to scan.


No request to identify an emotion.


A little time in which the listener decides what deserves their attention.


The person guiding needs to listen, too


Making room for choice changes how I write and speak.


I ask myself whether a cue is useful at that moment. I consider how many instructions I have already given. I leave pauses long enough for someone to adjust their position or decide they would rather do something else.


I also want to avoid turning every response into an interpretation.


If someone stops following a breath cue, I do not need to call it resistance. If they open their eyes, I do not need to ask them to close them again. If they prefer silence, I can respect that preference without assigning it a hidden meaning.


The person listening knows something I cannot know from outside: how this moment feels to them.


For therapists and practitioners using recordings


When a recording enters a therapy room or another professional space, I hope the choice to use it remains explicit.


Before pressing play, there can be a brief conversation about what the recording contains and whether the person wants to hear it. A simple way to pause can be agreed upon. Breathing guidance can be described in advance.


During listening, a person can change their mind.


That continuing choice matters to the way I want my work to be used. Permission given at the beginning should leave room for a different preference a few minutes later.


Nothing to catch up with


You may lose track of a count.


You may hear an invitation and decide to leave it alone.


You may breathe at a different pace throughout the entire recording.


There is nothing to catch up with.


In my work, I want the sound to offer a place to spend a little time. You can meet it with curiosity, distraction, tiredness, or whatever is present today.


My breath belongs to me.


Your breath belongs to you.


We can listen together and still have room for both.


Nothing is required.


Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

Julie Jules Smoot 

All audio recordings, guided listening experiences, and sound works on this site are created and voiced by Julie Jewels Smoot, JS Worldbridger and Author Honey Badger. 

​

No AI-generated voices, deepfake technology, or synthetic identity tools are used in the creation of this work. All recordings reflect original human performance, composition, and production.

​

The offerings on this site are presented as trauma-informed guided listening and sound experiences. They are not therapy, medical treatment, mental health care, or clinical services, and they are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any condition.

​

Participation is always optional. Listeners are free to pause, stop, or disengage at any time. No outcome, improvement, or response is promised or required.

​

This site provides pre-recorded audio content only and does not offer live facilitation, coaching, counseling, or real-time interaction unless explicitly stated.

​

By engaging with this content, you acknowledge that you are responsible for choosing the type of support that best meets your needs.

​

©2023 by Julie Jewels Smoot.  Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page